Dynamics and Stagnation in the Malthusian Epoch by Quamrul Ashraf and Oded Galor. Published in volume , issue 5, pages of American Economic. This paper empirically tests the predictions of the Malthusian theory with respect to both population dynamics and income per capita stagnation. This paper examines the central hypothesis of the influential Malthusian theory, according to which improvements in the technological environment during the.
|Published (Last):||28 January 2008|
|PDF File Size:||8.82 Mb|
|ePub File Size:||8.84 Mb|
|Price:||Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]|
Transition Timing, Land Productivity, and Income per Capita in CE Summary — This figure depicts the partial regression line for the malthusuan of transition timing land productivity on income per capita in the year CE, while controlling for the influence of land productivity transition timingabsolute latitude, access to waterways, and continental fixed effects.
The results from regressions explaining log population density in the year CE are presented in Table 2. Can Epidemics Explain the Three Regimes? Transition Timing, Land Productivity, and Population Density in CE Summary — This figure depicts, using the income per capita data-restricted samplethe partial regression line for the effect of transition timing land productivity on population density dynamis the year CE, while controlling for the influence of land productivity transition timingabsolute latitude, access to epoxh, and continental fixed effects.
Thus, for a given year, the x- and y-axes plot the residuals obtained from regressing the technology index and population density, respectively, for that year on the aforementioned set of covariates. Blackwell Publishers Ltd; The explanatory power of the regression in Column 3 improves by an additional 7 percentage points once controls epocn access to waterways are accounted for in Column 4, which constitutes the baseline regression specification for population density in CE.
Finally, regressions 5 and 6 represent the first stage of regressions 3 and 6respectively, in Table 9. Similarly, a 1 percent increase in land productivity generates, ceteris paribusa 0.
Regarding the historical population data from McEvedy and Joneswhile some of their estimates remain controversial, particularly those for sub-Saharan Africa and pre-Columbian Mesoamerica, a recent assessment malthsian, e. The most comprehensive worldwide cross-country historical estimates of population and income per capita since the year 1 CE have been assembled by Colin McEvedy and Richard Jones and Angus Maddison respectively.
Dynamics and Stagnation in the Malthusian Epoch
This section demonstrates the significant positive effects of land productivity and the level of technological advancement, as proxied by the timing of the Neolithic Revolution, on population density in the years CE and 1 CE. Thus, variations in favorable biogeographical factors i. In a world where labor dynakics perfectly mobile, regions with higher aggregate productivity would experience labor inflows until regional wage rates were equalized, implying that, in levels, technology should be positively associated with population density but should not be maltyusian with income per capita across regions.
The Origins of Ethnolinguistic Diversity: The closer the observations are to the degree line, the more uniformly distributed is the data and, hence, the larger is the cross-sectional variability. Nevertheless, the regression coefficients associated with the Neolithic transition-timing and land-productivity channels remain largely stable, albeit somewhat less so for the former, in comparison to their baseline estimates from Column 4 in Table 2.
DYNAMICS AND STAGNATION IN THE MALTHUSIAN EPOCH
Thus, in line with the predictions of the Malthusian theory, the results indicate that, during the agricultural stage of development, temporary gains due to improvements in the technological environment were indeed channeled into population growth, thereby leading more technologically advanced societies to sustain higher population densities. As predicted by the Malthusian theory, the slope coefficients in Columns 1 and 2 indicate that the change in the level of technology between the years BCE and 1 CE has a positive and statistically significant effect on the change in population density over the 1— CE time horizon.
Thus, Kremer does not test the absence of a long-run effect of the technological environment on income per capita nor does he examine the positive effect of technology on population size.
Theory and Evidence Working Paper: In particular, as a result of agglomeration and latitudinally-specific technology diffusion, the initial advantage enjoyed by equatorial societies during the Malthusian epoch became more pronounced over time. Without continental fixed effects, the coefficient of interest in Column 1 is 1. The finding that the negative elasticity of income per capita with respect to distance to the frontier is not only statistically insignificant but also at least an order of magnitude smaller than that of population density confirms Malthusian priors that the gains from trade and technology diffusion were primarily channeled into population growth rather than dtnamics improvements in living standards during pre-industrial times.
To summarize the main findings of the analysis thus far, the results indicate that more productive societies sustained higher population densities, as opposed to higher standards of living, during the time period 1— CE. Review of Economic Studies.
DYNAMICS AND STAGNATION IN THE MALTHUSIAN EPOCH
Moreover, the regional estimates sragnation McEvedy and Jones are also very similar to those presented in the more recent study by Massimo Livi-Bacci As argued by Jared Diamondan earlier onset of the Neolithic Revolution has been associated with a developmental head start that enabled the rise of a non-food-producing class whose members were essential for the advancement of written language, science and technology, and for the formation of cities, technology-based military powers and nation states.
The x-axis plots the cumulative fraction of the statnation corresponding to each observation in ascending orderand the y-axis plots the quantiles of the uniform distribution of log income per capita in CE.
The reader is referred to www. As argued by Diamondan earlier onset of the Neolithic Revolution has been associated stagnatkon a developmental head start that enabled the rise of a non-food-producing class whose members were essential for the advancement of written language, science and technology, and for the formation of cities, technology-based military powers and nation states.
In particular, the diffusion channel implies that, ceteris paribusthe greater the geographical distance from the technological leaders in a given period, the lower the level of economic development amongst the followers in that period. In particular, the analysis compares the results from estimating the following empirical models: In the communications sector, the index is assigned a value of 0 under the absence of both true writing and mnemonic or non-written records, a value of 1 under the presence of only mnemonic or non-written records, and a value of 2 under the presence of both.
Dynamivs output produced at time tY tis:. Finally, the partial regression lines associated with the period-specific indices of technology in the baseline regressions for population density in CE and 1 CE are depicted in Figures D.
Finally, given the possibility that the disturbance terms in the baseline regression models may be non-spherical in nature, particularly since economic development has been spatially clustered in certain regions of the world, Tables D.
Column 6 presents the IV regression results from estimating the baseline specification with log years since transition instrumented by the numbers of prehistoric domesticable species of plants and animals. In particular, maltusian number of specifications comprising different subsets of the explanatory variables in equation 15 are estimated to examine the independent and combined effects of the dnamics and land-productivity channels, while controlling for other geographical factors and continental fixed effects.
The evolution of income per worker is determined by the initial level of income per worker and the number of surviving children per adult. This section establishes that the Neolithic Revolution triggered a cumulative process of economic development, conferring a developmental head start to societies that experienced the agricultural transition earlier.